Uporabniški pogovor:Madyas

Your edits to Sarmati

Hello,

First please note that this is Slovenian wikipedia. Your edits to article Sarmati were reverted as they nowhere vaguely resemble proper Slovenian language.

Second, if your aim is to advocate Turkic origins of the Sarmatians, you must base your claims on reputable, scholarly sources. The current scholarly consensus is that they were an Iranian people or, at best, an amalgam of different ethnic groups. All of the available onomastic data, including their ethnic self-appelation "Sauromatae", are undisputably Iranian. The timeframe of their migrations to Eastern Europe is historically incongruous with the migrations of Turkic peoples. The English wikipedia mentions nothing of any Turkic origins of the Sarmatians. I had a look at one of the sources you added [1]. As a linguist, I can say that it is patently unscholarly work, based on klang-etymologies and hence unreliable.

Regards, Jalen (pogovor) 20:22, 28. februar 2015 (CET)

This place is not English Wikipedia. Madyas (pogovor) 13:15, 1. marec 2015 (CET)

English Wikipedia or not, all projects have the same basic policies and guidelines, which you do not follow (the same problem persists on en. WP, as evident from your user talk page). Either you will start to communicate and give arguments to the Jalen`s opinion above with reliable sources or you will be blocked for disruptive editing.--Archangel 13:39, 1. marec 2015 (CET)