Pogovor:Ignacij Hladnik

Same lifespan as Anton Schwab (1865-1932)?

Please see Pogovor:Anton Schwab (1865-1932). --Jura1 (pogovor) 11:55, 1. marec 2016 (CET)

Thank you for your notice. Ignacij Hladnik for sure has right data ([1]), and also Anton Schwab (1868-1938) ([2]). Still the question remains about Anton Schwab (1865-1932). His birth and death data seem to be copied from Ignacij Hladnik, also the data about "20 years conducting period at Dolenjsko pevsko društvo" is taken from Hladnik. On the other hand in Hladnik's article (Slovenska-biografija.si) there's no mention of Anton Foerster (mentioned in Anton Schwab (1865-1932)), besides Jskd.si and Rtvslo.si has a mention of Anton Schwab (1865–1932), which suggests he is a real person. But especially in the case of Rtvslo.si the mention is incorrectly used as a subtitle of a picture of Anton Schwab (1868-1938). Combining these data I am quite sure that Anton Schwab (1865-1932) as such actually has never existed and that the problem occured by mixing Hladnik's and Schwab's data. Therefore I think that the most reasonable thing in this case is a deletion of the article of Anton Schwab (1865-1932). --Janezdrilc (pogovor) 20:06, 1. marec 2016 (CET)

Sounds convincing. Thanks for researching it. I removed the data from d:Q18507508. We can delete that item once the article is gone. To avoid problems in the future, I added the incorrect years to d:Q18507509 with deprecated rank. This way it can be seen there that sometimes incorrect dates appear. --Jura1 (pogovor) 17:12, 2. marec 2016 (CET)

I deleted confusing article and disambigation page. If some day Anton Schwab (1865-1932) reapears as a real person I will restore pages. --Janezdrilc (pogovor) 18:37, 2. marec 2016 (CET)